Putting something into the vagina to kill sperm is among one of the oldest methods of contraception. Dating from ancient Egypt, there are records of using pessaries containing baking soda, honey, cooking oil, soapsuds, vinegar and many other substances, all of which could, in theory, kill sperm.
The first commercial spermicide was developed in 1885 by a London pharmacist, Walter Rendell, and a pessary bearing his name is still on sale in the UK. Many creams, gels, foams, pessaries and foaming tablets are now produced.
C-film, a novel product of the 1970s consisting of a 7-cm square of pliable soluble plastic impregnated with spermicide, may be placed over the head of the penis or over the cervix, making it the first contraceptive that can be used by either the woman or the man. It is not available in Australia.
Another novelty that became available in the USA and other countries in the mid-1980s is the ‘Today’ sponge – a concave disk of soft plastic sponge impregnated with spermicide. It is placed in the vagina over the cervix (where it would also be a reasonably good barrier) and is effective for the next 24 hours. The Today sponge was released in Australia during 1993.
Spermicides must be placed in the vagina before intercourse, allowing 11 minutes or more for those that must dissolve before they are active (pessaries, tablets). Spermicides work in several ways:
• by breaking down the surface membrane of sperm (soapsuds and the modern spermicides such as nonoxynol-9)
• by being too acid or alkaline for sperm to survive (vinegar, soda)
• by causing fluid to be leached from sperm (honey, strong salt solution)
• by containing substances that poison sperm.
The only spermicides recommended now are chemicals that break down the sperm surface membrane (surfactants). All others, including soapsuds, are toxic or irritating to the vaginal lining.
Effectiveness of spermicides
Since 1970 Australian health authorities have recommended that the following statement appear on all spermicide packs: «CAUTION: For contraceptive purposes, this product should be used only in conjunction with an occlusive device (diaphragm or condom).’
The effect of this statement is that the use of spermicides for contraception is now uncommon. Most people think it pans that they are useless, and even pose who have used them successfully for years must have doubts about their efficacy. However, spermicides are a great deal better than nothing in preventing pregnancy though there are greater variations in their reported effectiveness than for any other contraceptive method, ranging from 1 per cent to 30 per cent failure rate! Even at the worst rate they would prevent two-thirds of the pregnancies expected in a year. If this were more widely known and if women were willing to use them, there would be fewer unmanned pregnancies and requests for portion.
One USA study of 3000 women who had
been given proper instructions about the use of spermicides reported four pregnancies per hundred woman-years. This is probably a realistic failure rate for couples who use the spermicide properly every time they have sex.
Advantages of spermicides
• No prescription is needed.
• They are easy to use (cream, jelly and foam come with an introducer).
• Side-effects are rare with modem surfactants.
• In the laboratory, nonoxynol-9 destroys some of the micro-organisms that cause sexually transmissible diseases.
Disadvantages of spermicides
• Some couples find them distasteful or messy.
• Some people develop an allergic rash from them.
• They are relatively expensive.
• The effects of absorbed spermicide are unknown.
A worry about spermicides was raised in 1981 by a claim that their use has been associated with an increased rate of birth defects. This triggered several large, careful studies of the birth histories of couples who had ever used spermicides. Fortunately, these studies found no evidence to support the claim.
Things that won’t work for contraception are:
• douching (squirting water, Coca-cola or any other fluid into the vagina)
• jumping up and down after sex
• hot baths
• lunar or astrological methods
• having sex standing up.
*136/31/5*